There is an interesting debate swirling over at the doctorwho community surrounding the show’s portrayal of ethnic characters over the past four seasons. I’ve been thinking about it and puzzling it over in my head and wondering if I’m just woefully ignorant.
Because I can’t see it.
Oh, sure, on paper I read the snippets of information and (depending on phrasing) it can sound quite bad. Put it in the episode, though, and I don’t pick up on anything wrong. Quite the opposite. I’ve often thought Doctor Who was refreshing in that people of different ethnicities kissing, dating, and just plain being friends, is still not something I’ve found to be common on North American television.
There are, of course, a few examples people have pointed to.
The Last of the Time LordsOn paper: The majority of black characters are reduced to servant roles and are abused.
Watching the episode: It doesn’t give me pause. The Master is angry at Martha. The Master wants to hurt and humiliate her. Capturing her family and abusing them seems logical. Wait, her family is black? No, still seems logical.
Mickey the IdiotOn paper: Doctor frequently calls series one token black man idiot.
Watching the show: Mickey the idiot started with the Doctor number nine. Nine was very jealous and possessive of Rose – even to the extent that he tries to separate her from Jackie. Mickey is one of the things tethering Rose to home. It makes sense in series one for Nine to belittle him (plus, you’ve got to admit he probably did seem like an idiot to the Doctor in the first episode). By the end of series two the dynamic quite shifts and the Doctor is really quite fond of him.
Human Nature/Family of BloodOn Paper: Martha ends up as second class citizen and servant, also plays role of “noble, self-sacrificing black woman”.
Watching the episode: Well, first off the episode is based on a novel which takes place during the Doctors seventh incarnation. There was no Martha. In order to fit her into the plot they had to give her a role. It’s 1913 and, sadly, the role they gave her is a realistic one. Some people have complained about the story adaptation and stated that it should not have been attempted while a black woman was playing the companion. But why not? It’s an uncomfortable situation and an uncomfortable time period. Surely it’s not bad to portray this on screen?